Florida travel advice usually falls into one of two categories. It either sends visitors directly toward the biggest attractions or assumes they are willing to drive from Miami to Key West and back before lunch. I wanted something more realistic.
My experiment was simple: What would happen if I let Florida Redditors design one ideal day?
To be clear, I planned this itinerary rather than physically completing it. Reddit supplied the recommendations, but I checked every stop against official business, city, and attraction information. The strongest cluster of compatible suggestions centered on St. Petersburg, where beaches, gardens, museums, Cuban sandwiches, and old-fashioned smoked fish fit into one ambitious—but possible—day.
Breakfast on Pass-a-Grille Beach — 7:30 a.m.
Several Reddit discussions treated Pass-a-Grille as the quieter and more appealing alternative to Florida’s busier tourist beaches. Paradise Grille also appeared repeatedly as the obvious place to begin, largely because it lets visitors eat breakfast steps from the Gulf.
Paradise Grille opens daily at 7 a.m. and serves breakfast alongside its burgers, seafood, and beach food. The combination of coffee, eggs, and an unobstructed waterfront view gives this itinerary an appropriately Floridian start without requiring anything more complicated than finding parking.
That last part could be the first challenge. Pass-a-Grille has more than 700 public spaces between Gulf Way and Pass-a-Grille Way, but weekend parking costs $6 per hour and can become difficult later in the day. Arriving early should make both parking and breakfast considerably easier.
I would allow approximately 90 minutes for breakfast and a short walk near the southern jetty before heading inland.
Explore Sunken Gardens — 10 a.m.
Redditors looking for something beyond St. Petersburg’s beaches repeatedly recommended Sunken Gardens. One recent discussion described it as one of the last surviving pieces of old roadside Florida, which makes it an ideal contrast to the modern resorts along the coast.
Sunken Gardens opens at 10 a.m. Monday through Saturday and noon on Sunday. Adult admission is $18, and tickets are purchased in person. The attraction recommends allowing roughly 90 minutes to two hours to explore its tropical plants, flamingos, waterfalls, history center, and garden shop.
This stop is approximately 25 to 30 minutes from Pass-a-Grille under normal conditions. To keep the itinerary workable, I would schedule the experiment for a Saturday and leave the gardens around 11:30 a.m.
Get a Cuban Sandwich at Bodega — Noon
Reddit had apparently decided that no respectable St. Petersburg day could continue without a Cuban sandwich appearing somewhere in the schedule.
Bodega on Central came up several times, including one particularly practical suggestion to take its sandwiches next door to Green Bench Brewing. Other users praised the restaurant’s plantains and regularly listed its Cuban among the city’s essential foods.
Bodega opens at 11 a.m. and operates as a casual, order-at-the-window restaurant in the EDGE District. Its official website describes the Cuban sandwich as one of its signature items and also lists vegetarian and vegan options.
Lunch should take approximately an hour. Anyone interested in adding a drink could walk around the corner to Green Bench Brewing, which opens at noon. However, lingering too long would make the afternoon portion of this plan much harder.
Spend the Afternoon at The Dalí — 1:30 p.m.
Florida Redditors frequently recommend St. Petersburg’s museums, but The Dalí consistently receives the strongest “you cannot leave without seeing this” treatment.
The Dalí Museum is only a short drive from Bodega and is open daily from 10 a.m. until 6 p.m, with extended hours on Thursdays. Adult gallery admission is $32, while onsite parking costs $10 and is available on a first-come, first-served basis.
I would reserve around two hours for the museum. That would provide enough time to see the permanent collection and explore the building without attempting to absorb every artwork at sprinting speed.
Purchasing a timed ticket beforehand would be the safest move, especially on a weekend. Anyone trying to reduce the cost could replace the museum with a walk through St. Petersburg’s mural-filled Central Arts District, but The Dalí makes the planned day feel more distinctive.
Return to Pass-a-Grille for Sunset — 4:30 p.m.
Doubling back to Pass-a-Grille is the least efficient part of the itinerary, but Reddit’s enthusiasm for its sunsets makes the detour difficult to avoid.
The drive from downtown St. Petersburg should take roughly 25 minutes without severe traffic. Arriving approximately an hour before sunset provides time to park, walk the beach, and find a good viewing spot. Exact sunset times change throughout the month, so visitors should check the forecast before leaving downtown.
Parking presents the same expense as it did during breakfast, but this return trip is where the beach earns its place in the itinerary. The morning stop provides quiet water and breakfast, while the evening visit delivers the full Gulf Coast sunset experience.
Finish With Smoked Fish and Key Lime Pie — 6:15 p.m.
Reddit offered plenty of upscale dinner suggestions, but Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish felt more appropriate after an already expensive museum-and-beach day. It is also a distinctly local experience rather than another polished waterfront restaurant.
Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish has served smoked seafood since 1951. Its fish is prepared over red oak for four to six hours, and the restaurant is open Wednesday through Sunday from 11:30 a.m. until 7:30 p.m.
Dinner prices currently range from $20.50 for smoked mullet to $34.50 for amberjack. A slice of key lime pie costs $7.25, conveniently solving the dessert portion of the assignment without adding another drive. Prices and availability can change.
Would This Florida Day Actually Work?
Yes, but only with an early start and some discipline.
The complete route would involve about 50 miles of driving and 90 minutes to two hours in the car, depending on beach and downtown traffic. The expected cost is roughly $120 to $170 per person after food, attraction tickets, parking, taxes, and tips. Two people sharing parking expenses would land closer to the lower end.
The Dalí is the only stop I would strongly recommend booking ahead. Sunken Gardens sells admission in person, while Paradise Grille, Bodega, and Ted Peters are casual enough to approach without building the entire day around reservations.
If I changed anything, I would remove either the morning or evening visit to Pass-a-Grille. Visiting twice creates unnecessary backtracking, even if breakfast and sunset offer very different experiences. Still, Reddit’s version of the perfect Florida day is surprisingly coherent: begin beside the Gulf, explore a piece of old Florida, eat a Cuban sandwich, see world-class art, watch the sunset, and finish with smoked fish and key lime pie.
It is busy, slightly impractical, and extremely Florida.
